top of page

One month without card surcharges: the data says most merchants absorbed, a small cohort repriced hard

Nov 3
6 min read

TL;DR: One month after Australia’s card surcharge ban took effect, the evidence points to two different merchant responses. Tyro data says almost nine in 10 businesses did not raise prices after 1 October. A minority did, and among businesses that previously surcharged and then repriced, 61 per cent raised prices by more than three times their old surcharge. For operators, the immediate priority is to help merchants make decisions from their actual merchant service charge (MSF), not anecdotes, ahead of a possible January–February repricing wave.

What does the first month of data show? Most merchants held prices steady

The month-one scorecard is not a story of universal price rises. Tyro’s transaction data, reported by news.com.au on 2 November, found that almost nine in 10 businesses did not increase prices after the ban began on 1 October 2026.

The response differed according to whether a business had previously surcharged. Of those that had, 12.4 per cent raised their base prices. Among businesses that had never surcharged, 2.7 per cent put prices up. But the increases made by a small subset stand out: 61 per cent of previously surcharging businesses that raised prices increased them by more than three times their former surcharge. That group represented 7.6 per cent of all previously surcharging shops.

This is the important distinction for a retail payment strategy: the overall response has been restrained, while a relatively small cohort has made much larger adjustments. Tyro chief executive Nigel Lee said the vast majority had not raised prices, and that cases of increases well beyond previous surcharges were happening “in a very small number of cases”. He also cautioned that businesses face different costs and pressures, so not every increase can be attributed solely to the ban.

Two flowing transaction streams diverge into soft emerald particles and a rising amber repricing path

What do café prices tell us? Some rose, but the data needs context

SmallFlatWhite.com’s October tracker provides a closer look at cafés. It priced 10,059 cafés and more than nine million menu items, twice as many venues as its April survey. About 20 per cent of cafés across Australia raised coffee prices in October, most commonly by 50 cents. Prices rose around three times faster that month than the average over the previous five months.

The average small flat white was $5.16 in October, up from $5.01 in April; a large averaged $6.31. Since April, 45 per cent of cafés have raised prices. Queensland cafés were most likely to put prices up in October, at 22 per cent, followed by NSW and Victoria at 21 per cent each. South Australia was least likely, at 12 per cent. At the same cafés, the largest increases since April were in Canberra, up 4.3 per cent, Brisbane, up 4.0 per cent, and Melbourne, up 3.7 per cent. Sydney was the cheapest capital city for a small flat white at $4.95; Darwin was the most expensive at $5.52.

The tracker also found that 72 per cent of cafés had kept prices unchanged through September, while 9 per cent had gone cheaper. These figures show price movement, not its cause. SmallFlatWhite.com founder Chris Drake described the surcharge as “the last straw” for businesses already facing higher costs and cash-flow pressures. He also pointed to supplier price rises and predicted that more cafés would reprice in January or February.

That forecast is a signal to watch, not a guaranteed outcome. A price rise after 1 October does not, by itself, prove the surcharge ban caused it.

Why does acquirer fee transparency matter now? It gives merchants a number to work from

The decision to absorb costs or adjust prices should start with the merchant’s actual MSF, not a general market anecdote or the surcharge they used to display.

Acquirer fee tables published on 30 October, including Table 21 MSF data, give merchants a new reference point for understanding charges across payment categories. They do not necessarily disclose an individual merchant’s negotiated rate, but they make it easier to ask informed questions and compare pricing. Our guide to Australia’s first acquirer fee tables explains what the disclosures can, and cannot, show.

For POS companies, ISOs, PayFacs and acquirers, this is a practical opportunity: help merchants connect their statement data, payment mix and pricing decisions. A lower interchange rate does not automatically mean every merchant’s total acceptance cost has fallen by the same amount.

Glowing data ribbon moving from an October-like node towards a larger amber January–February horizon

Why could January and February be the next pricing test?

The most important commercial event may still be ahead. Drake’s forecast of more café price rises in January or February suggests that some businesses may be delaying decisions while they assess costs, seasonal trading and the effect of the surcharge change.

Operators should treat this as a scenario to prepare for, not a prediction that all merchants will reprice. The first month establishes a baseline: most businesses held prices steady, some repriced, and a small group made steep increases. If a wider cohort reviews prices at the new year, merchants will need a clear explanation of what is driving the decision.

Our earlier coverage looked at what the first week without surcharging meant. This month-one review is different: it assesses the observed response and what payment operators should advise next.

How are issuer changes affecting the wider payment picture?

Merchant pricing is only one side of the reset. From 1 October, the domestic consumer credit interchange cap fell from 0.8 per cent to 0.3 per cent. The RBA estimated this change would cost banks about $660 million a year. Before the ban, Australians paid around $1.6 billion of the $1.8 billion annual surcharge total passed on by small businesses.

Banks are also adjusting card economics. ANZ has increased interest rates; NAB has increased annual fees and changed its points system; and CBA has ended fee waivers for cardholders meeting certain spending limits, replacing them with voucher access, and introduced international transaction fees.

Across card programmes, the areas of potential loss for customers include: interchange funding; points earn rates; sign-up bonuses; airline transfer value; complimentary insurance; spend-based fee waivers; interest costs; international transaction fees; lounge access and loyalty features; and cashbacks or statement credits. The scale and combination of changes vary by issuer and product. Professor Steve Worthington of Swinburne University said heavy credit card users “will lose out” on bonuses and perks, and suggested these changes could be “the beginning of the demise of credit cards”.

As rewards erode, consumer choice may shift over time. Merchants and payment providers should watch debit, BNPL and wallet mix, as well as cash use. With no card surcharge, cash users have one less reason to carry cash. Another pressure on its decline. Changes in contactless payments and wallet use may also affect the mix of transactions merchants accept.

For more background on the policy changes, see our overview of Australia’s October 2026 card reforms.

What should merchants and payment operators do now?

Use the first month to prepare for deliberate decisions rather than reactive price changes:

  1. Pull the actual MSF from the new acquirer fee tables and the merchant’s own statements.

  2. Model the true cost of acceptance against the merchant’s real payment mix, including card type and channel.

  3. Decide deliberately whether to absorb or reprice before the January–February period Drake predicts.

  4. Keep pricing claims accurate. The ACCC has warned businesses not to attribute increases solely to the surcharge ban when other factors are involved.

  5. Track payment behaviour, including card, debit, BNPL, wallet and cash use, as issuer rewards and fees change.

The ATO’s short-lived plan to stop accepting credit cards from 1 December adds a reminder of how unsettled the transition remains. After Treasurer Jim Chalmers intervened, the decision was delayed; ATO Commissioner Rob Heferen later conceded at a Senate estimates hearing that the agency had “jumped to conclusions”.

Abstract balance between an amber price form and emerald card, phone wallet and cash-like payment shapes

Frequently asked questions about the first month of the surcharge ban

Did most Australian businesses raise prices after the card surcharge ban?

No. Tyro data found almost nine in 10 businesses did not raise prices after 1 October. Price responses varied, and a small cohort of previously surcharging businesses made increases well above its former surcharge.

Does every price increase after 1 October relate to the ban?

No. Tyro’s Nigel Lee said businesses face different operating costs and pressures, and not every increase is solely because of the ban. The ACCC has warned against misleading consumers by blaming the ban when other factors are involved.

What should a merchant check before changing prices?

Start with the merchant’s actual MSF, its payment mix and its total cost of acceptance. Use the published acquirer fee tables as a benchmark, then model whether absorbing costs or changing all-in prices makes commercial sense.

Are more price rises expected in January or February?

SmallFlatWhite.com founder Chris Drake predicts that most cafés will put prices up in January or February. That is a forecast, not a confirmed outcome; merchants and operators should prepare for the possibility and monitor the data.

Key takeaway

One month in, the evidence does not support a blanket claim that Australian merchants broadly replaced surcharges with higher prices. Most held steady. A minority repriced, and a smaller cohort raised prices sharply. The next test is whether merchants use transparent MSF data to make measured decisions, or whether a broader new-year repricing wave develops while issuer economics and customer payment choices are also shifting.

 
 
bottom of page