Merchants Sue the OCC and NCUA Over the Illinois Interchange Law Preemption
TL;DR
Nine trade associations have opened a new legal front in the Illinois interchange dispute, suing the OCC and NCUA over how the agencies moved to pre-empt the state law. Their cases argue that the regulators exceeded their authority and bypassed required notice-and-comment procedures. This is distinct from the federal Credit Card Competition Act, which would mandate competing networks and merchant routing choice.
The practical question is now who gets to shape card fees: Congress, courts, federal regulators, or states. For payment operators, the immediate issue is that Illinois’s law still applies to state-chartered banks and credit unions, and tax-and-tip fee calculations may require changes to point-of-sale and payment systems.
What are the merchants challenging?
The lawsuits challenge the federal agencies’ process and authority, not the underlying Illinois law directly. On Thursday, 12 November 2026, nine trade associations filed separate cases in the US District Court for the District of Columbia against the Office of the Comptroller of the Currency (OCC) and the National Credit Union Administration (NCUA).
The plaintiffs are the National Retail Federation, National Grocers Association, FMI – The Food Industry Association, National Association of Convenience Stores, Restaurant Law Center, Retail Litigation Center, Illinois Fuel & Retail Association, Illinois Restaurant Association and Illinois Retail Merchants Association.
The OCC case argues that the agency “skipped over the notice-and-comment procedures required by the Administrative Procedure Act and the National Bank Act” when it issued its rule and pre-emption order. In a statement, the NRF said: “Nothing in the National Bank Act, or in the OCC's poorly reasoned, slapdash rule, authorizes such collusive and excessive fees on merchants that are not being provided banking services in exchange for those fees.”
The separate NCUA lawsuit argues that nothing in the Federal Credit Union Act pre-empts the Illinois law, and that the NCUA exceeded its authority and failed to follow the Administrative Procedure Act’s notice-and-comment requirements. These are the plaintiffs’ claims, not findings by a court.
The legal significance is that merchants are now contesting the regulators’ actions themselves. The earlier litigation was brought by banking and credit union associations challenging the Illinois statute. The new cases ask whether federal agencies used lawful authority and procedures to displace it.

How is this different from the Credit Card Competition Act?
The Illinois law concerns interchange on tax and tip portions of a transaction; the CCCA concerns payment routing. Those are different mechanisms, even though both sit within the broader US debate about card costs.
Illinois’s Interchange Fee Prohibition Act (IFPA), signed by Governor JB Pritzker in June 2024, would prohibit interchange fees on the tax and gratuity portions of consumer card transactions. By contrast, the federal Credit Card Competition Act, S.3623, would require covered issuers to enable competing payment networks and give merchants a choice of routing.
For background on the federal bill, see The Interchange Bill Just Lost Its Two Champions. It Isn't Dead.. That is a routing-policy debate. The new lawsuits are about administrative process and the limits of federal agency pre-emption.
This dispute also fits a wider pattern of courts and regulators shaping interchange outcomes. A Federal Appeals Court Just Struck Down the Fed's 21-Cent Debit Cap: The Rewrite Begins explores another example, though the legal issue and parties differ.
Why does the Illinois law still matter to operators?
Federal pre-emption has not removed every Illinois institution from the law’s reach. The OCC moved to pre-empt the IFPA in April 2026, and the NCUA followed with its own rule for credit unions on 30 June. A September ruling expanded the injunction to include national credit unions.
National banks, federal savings and loans, out-of-state chartered banks and card networks are also exempt under the existing actions. State-chartered banks and credit unions remain subject to the act. Digital Transactions reports that about 235 state-chartered banks and nearly 200 state-chartered credit unions operate in Illinois.
Illinois lawmakers have delayed implementation until 1 July 2027. If the legal position remains divided, merchants and providers could face a split acceptance market, with different implications depending on the institution involved in a transaction. That is an operational scenario to prepare for, not a settled outcome.
The technical challenge is more specific than simply changing a fee table. Calculating interchange only on the non-tax, non-tip portion requires the transaction data to identify and separate tax and gratuity amounts. POS systems, PayFacs and acquirers need to establish whether their systems can pass and retain those itemised amounts through the payment flow. If a ticket cannot be split reliably, accurate compliance becomes difficult.
Illinois Fuel & Retail Association data cited in the merchants’ lawsuit puts merchants’ annual interchange payments on taxes and tips at at least $242 million. The Merchants Payments Coalition says the law could save Illinois merchants and customers about $500 million a year. Those are industry estimates, not guaranteed savings. The lawsuits state that Visa and Mastercard handle “over 80%” of card transactions covered by the law.
What is the wider political and legal backdrop?
The pre-emption cases add another decision-making forum to an already crowded policy landscape. Congress may consider federal routing legislation. The Seventh Circuit is handling the appeal over the Illinois law. The OCC and NCUA have issued pre-emption rules. State legislatures are considering their own interchange measures, and federal courts will now hear the merchants’ challenges to the agencies.
Illinois signed the IFPA in June 2024, and bank and credit union associations sued in August that year. Judge Virginia Kendall upheld some parts of the law in February 2026, then blocked parts through an injunction, reported in June. Both Illinois and the bank associations are appealing. The Seventh Circuit has scheduled arguments for 27 January 2027; plaintiffs’ briefs are due 21 December, while the Illinois Attorney General’s brief is due 23 November.
The statehouse activity is also material. The Electronic Transactions Association (ETA) says 32 interchange-related bills were introduced in 20 states, Washington DC and Puerto Rico in 2026, and 75 have been introduced since 2025 across 32 states. Active proposals include Pennsylvania HB 2090 and SB 1202, Massachusetts SB 688, and New Jersey SB 4360 and AB 5014. These measures would prohibit interchange on sales tax and, in some cases, gratuities. None has passed, and legislative sessions are due to adjourn between 30 November 2026 and 5 January 2027.
The merchants’ lawsuit says the OCC’s actions “cast significant doubt on the ability of states like Illinois to pass legislation that relieves merchants and consumers of these substantial financial burdens and thus will chill other States from doing so.” The ETA’s executive vice-president Scott Talbott responded on Thursday: “We are confident the OCC's actions will pass muster.” The outcome could influence how other states assess similar proposals, but it remains for the courts to decide.
What should payment businesses monitor now?
Treat the next milestones as planning triggers, not predictions of the final legal result. Operators selling into Illinois should map which issuer and institution types are affected, check transaction-level tax and tip data, and identify where POS, PayFac or acquirer systems cannot split a ticket.
The key dates are the Illinois Attorney General’s brief on 23 November, the plaintiffs’ brief on 21 December, Seventh Circuit arguments on 27 January 2027, state legislative adjournments from 30 November to 5 January, and the current Illinois implementation date of 1 July 2027.
Interchange pricing pressure is also arriving through litigation over the US swipe-fee settlement, with a final-approval hearing scheduled for Monday, 16 November in the Eastern District of New York. For the settlement’s potential merchant steering implications, see The US Swipe-Fee Settlement Gets Its Day in Court, and the Steering Era May Begin.
Australia offers a useful contrast. Its Reserve Bank reforms combine interchange caps and a surcharge ban under national regulation. The US picture is less uniform: state laws, federal bills, agency pre-emption and court cases overlap. For processors and merchants, that difference matters. A national rule can provide a more consistent baseline; a patchwork can require systems and compliance processes that account for jurisdiction and institution type. See Australia's surcharge ban and interchange changes for the Australian context.

Frequently asked questions
What is the Illinois Interchange Fee Prohibition Act?
The IFPA is an Illinois law that would prohibit interchange fees on the tax and tip portions of credit and debit card transactions. Its implementation is currently delayed until 1 July 2027.
Why are merchants suing the OCC and NCUA?
The trade associations argue that the agencies exceeded their statutory authority and failed to follow required notice-and-comment procedures when issuing rules and orders to pre-empt the Illinois law.
Does federal pre-emption cover every bank and credit union in Illinois?
No. The current actions exempt national banks, federal savings and loans, out-of-state chartered banks, card networks and national credit unions. State-chartered banks and credit unions remain subject to the act.
Is this the same as the Credit Card Competition Act?
No. The CCCA is a proposed federal routing mandate. The Illinois law concerns interchange fees on the tax and tip portions of transactions. The new lawsuits challenge federal agencies’ pre-emption process and authority.
What is the main operational issue for payment providers?
Systems may need to identify and separate tax and gratuity amounts from the purchase amount to calculate applicable interchange correctly. Providers should assess whether their transaction data and processing flows support that level of detail.
